Skip to contentSkip to headerSkip to cartSkip to footer

Beard Oil vs Beard Balm: Which One Do You Actually Need?

Author: Faiysal Kothiwala

Updated at: Dec 09, 2024

By Faiysal Kothiwala, Founder & CEO of The Beard Struggle. Updated October 2026.

Day Liquid Beard Tonic in morning light beside Night Liquid Elixir at night. Beard oil for morning and for bedtime.

Short answer: beard oil is for the skin, beard balm is for the hair. Oil is a thin liquid that soaks into the skin under your beard, the skin that gets dry, itchy and flaky. Use it every day at any length, stubble included. Balm is oils set with beeswax and plant butters, so it sits on the hair, shapes the beard and pins down flyaways. It earns its place once you have about 4 cm (1.5 inches) to control. If you have a full beard, the normal routine is both: oil first, balm on top.

That is the whole answer for most men. The rest of this page explains why, shows what our customers actually do, and settles the questions people type into Google right after this one.

Key takeaways

  • Start with beard oil. It conditions the skin under the beard at any length, stubble included.
  • Add balm at about 4 cm (1.5 inches), when there is enough hair to shape.
  • Oil goes on first, balm on top. Never the other way round.
  • Night is oil only. Balm on a pillow is wasted wax.
  • If you are buying one product, buy the oil. Most of our customers do and never need anything else.
Beard oil Beard balm
What it is Liquid blend of carrier oils Oils set with beeswax and plant butters
Main job Condition hair and skin Condition, plus light hold and shape
Hold None Light to medium
Best length Any, including stubble 4 cm and up
When it goes on First, on a clean dry beard After oil, as the finishing layer
Beeswax No Yes
Lasts (daily use) A 30 ml bottle, about 6 to 7 weeks A 50 g tin, about 10 weeks
TBS product Day Liquid Beard Tonic, Night Liquid Elixir Warrior's Beard Balm

Beard oil dropper bottle and open beard balm jar side by side. Oil conditions the skin, balm shapes the hair.

How we learned this: 30 batches and a barbershop

I started The Beard Struggle in Vancouver in 2015 because the balm everyone was buying did not work. I was getting a haircut almost every week back then, and every week the line at the counter for one beard balm was longer. It was a soft, coconut-oil-heavy blend. It made a beard soft for about an hour, then the beard dried out and went rough again. The guys selling it pitched growth. That was never true of any balm, theirs or ours.

So I ordered the beard balms Amazon showed me. Some smelled bad. Some had the wrong texture. Some never fully melted in the hand and left specks of wax stuck in my beard all day. That taught me the first rule of balm: the wax has to be measured, not guessed. Too little and there is no hold. Too much and the balm is sticky and drags through the hair. That is why mustache wax, which needs to hold a shape all day, carries far more wax than a beard balm.

The second rule took longer. Every oil and butter behaves differently on a face. We tested hundreds of carrier oils and 20 to 30 butters. Some were too heavy. Some did not condition the hair. Some sat in the pores. It took 20 to 30 batches before the balance was right, tested on friends, on strangers with beards, on men who answered our Instagram DMs about their own beard struggles, and on my own beard as it grew. Every new length showed a new problem. When my beard got long enough to get dirty, we made a wash and a conditioner. The whole range grew that way.

What we put in, and what we leave out

No coconut oil. It is in most body butters for a reason: it is heavy, and it works on the body. On the face, used every day, it builds up and is widely rated as one of the oils most likely to clog pores. The same goes for some heavy butters. The skin under a beard is face skin, so we only use oils and butters that sit right on it.

Day Liquid Beard Tonic: crambe abyssinica seed oil, sunflower seed oil, vitamin E, babassu seed oil, squalane, jojoba seed oil, fragrance and castor seed oil.

Night Liquid Elixir: crambe abyssinica seed oil, babassu seed oil, squalane, fragrance, jojoba seed oil and castor seed oil. Fewer, richer oils, because it has to last the night.

Warrior's Beard Balm: shea butter, sweet almond oil, rice bran oil, beeswax, chia seed oil, macadamia seed oil, rosehip oil, avocado oil, fragrance, vitamin E, crambe seed oil, black goji seed extract and kukui seed oil.

All three contain nut-derived oils. If you have a tree nut allergy, do not use them. If your skin reacts to fragrance, try a small amount on your inner arm and wait 24 hours before using it on your face.

What beard oil does

Beard oil is a skin product that happens to go on through a beard. No wax, no hold. A good one is a blend of carrier oils thin enough to get through the hair and absorb into the skin beneath it without sitting on top as grease. On the hair itself it does one thing: coats it and adds shine.

Diagram showing beard oil soaking through the hair into the skin, and beard balm coating the hair with beeswax for hold. Oil first, balm second.

The skin part matters more than most men realize. Beard itch, flakes and the dry, wiry feel of a new beard all start at the skin. Oil is the product in this comparison that reaches it best, because it is thin enough to get through the hair.

Our two oils, Day Liquid Beard Tonic and Night Liquid Elixir, share a base of crambe abyssinica seed oil (Abyssinian oil, a light plant oil that absorbs fast), castor, babassu, squalane (a plant-derived oil very close to the oil your skin makes itself; squalene is about 13% of human sebum, per Huang, Lin and Fang, Molecules, 2009) and jojoba, but they are not the same recipe. The Day Tonic adds sunflower oil and vitamin E and is the lighter of the two, built to absorb fast and disappear under a workday. The Night Elixir leans on babassu and squalane instead, so it is the richer oil and built to sit on the skin while you sleep. There is no argan, no coconut, no mineral oil and no DHT blocker in either, so neither works against growth (DHT is the hormone that drives beard growth; some oils add ingredients meant to suppress it, which is the last thing a beard needs). Both are Leaping Bunny certified, an independent certification that no animal testing is used at any stage of making the product, and come in a 30 ml glass bottle. Babassu is nut-derived, so check with your doctor if you have a tree nut allergy.

What beard balm does

Balm takes the conditioning job and adds structure. The ingredient that makes the difference is beeswax. It coats each hair, holds it where you put it, and leaves a low shine that reads as healthy rather than oily.

Warrior's Beard Balm 50 g tin by The Beard Struggle.

Everything else in a balm, the oils, the butters, the vitamin E, does the same work it does in an oil, just less of it per gram because wax and butter take up room in the tin. That is why balm is a second layer and not a replacement. It cannot reach the skin the way a liquid can.

Warrior's Beard Balm is shea butter, sweet almond, rice bran, beeswax, chia, macadamia, rosehip, avocado, crambe and kukui, in a 50 g tin. Hold is light to medium: enough to tame flyaways and set a part, not enough to sculpt a handlebar. For that you want a wax.

Hold, for a balm, means how long the beard stays where you brushed it. Light hold: flyaways stay down for a few hours. Medium hold: the shape lasts the working day and you can still run your fingers through it. Firm hold, where the hair stays put until you wash it, is wax territory.

Brand Viking Danzbeard breaks down what oil does, what balm does, and when to reach for each.

How to use oil and balm together

Morning routine: wash, oil first with Day Liquid Tonic, balm second from 4 cm. Night routine: Night Liquid Elixir only, no balm.

Order matters. Oil conditions. Balm seals and shapes. Reverse them and the wax blocks the oil from reaching the skin, which is the whole point of the oil.

Morning

  1. Wash or rinse, then towel dry until the beard is damp, not wet.
  2. Oil first. 3 to 4 drops for a short beard, 6 to 8 for a full one. Rub your palms together, work it in from the skin outward, then comb through.
  3. Balm second, if your beard is 4 cm or longer, while the beard is still damp from the shower. The water left in the hair mixes with the oils and the beard comes out noticeably softer than if you wait until it is bone dry. Scrape a pea to dime size of balm, warm it between your palms until it turns to oil, work it through, then shape with a brush.

Bearded man applying Day Liquid Beard Tonic with a dropper: start clean and dry, warm a few drops, work through the beard to the skin.

Bearded man applying beard oil, then working beard balm through his beard. Condition with oil, finish with balm.

Night

Oil only. A few drops before bed, worked into the skin. Skip the balm; wax on a pillow does nothing for your beard and something for your laundry. This is where the Night Liquid Elixir fits: the richer of our two oils, built on babassu and squalane so it stays on the skin through the night instead of disappearing in an hour.

Day Liquid Tonic and Night Liquid Elixir bottles side by side. When to use each oil, how much, and where to apply.

The mistake I see most: men think beard oil is for the beard. It isn't. Oil does very little for the hair itself beyond coating it and adding shine. Its job is the skin underneath, the skin that gets itchy, dry and flaky and gives a lot of men beardruff. That is what the oil fixes. The balm is for the hairs: it shapes them and holds the style. And if the hair itself is coarse and needs softening, that is the butter's job, not the oil's.

What our customers actually buy

We sell both, so we can see how men actually settle the oil vs balm question with their wallets. These figures cover twelve months of US and Canadian orders, October 2025 to October 2026, counting only orders that contained a single oil, balm, butter or cream (kits and free samples excluded). The two countries agree almost to the percentage point.

Bar chart: 77% of beard-care orders include an oil, 53% a balm, 23% a cream, 21% a butter. Most common first purchase is oil and balm together at 28%.

  • Oil is the default. 77% of beard-care orders include an oil. Balm is in 53%, cream in 23%, butter in 21%.
  • Most men buy both from day one. The single most common first purchase is oil and balm together (28% of first orders). Oil on its own is second at 22%. Balm on its own is 8%.
  • Oil-only is a stable habit. Balm-only is not. Of repeat customers whose first order was oil alone, 60% never bought anything else and 28% later added balm. Of those who started with balm alone, 36% later added oil. Men who start with balm tend to discover they needed oil. Men who start with oil often find it is all they need.
  • Day beats night about 1.4 to 1. Day Liquid Beard Tonic outsells Night Liquid Elixir in units, which lines up with the routine above: oil every morning, and a second application at night if you want it.

What this tells you: if you are deciding between the two, start with oil. You are statistically likely to be happy with just that. Add balm when the beard gets long enough to need shaping, and you will be in the same place as the largest group of our customers.

The question I get more than any other is "oil or balm?" and almost every man who asks it thinks the oil is for the hair. I correct him: the oil is for the skin, the balm is for the hair. The reaction is always the same. He goes quiet for a second, then tells me he has been doing it wrong his whole life. Years of rubbing oil into the ends of his beard and wondering why the skin underneath still itched. One sentence fixes it. That sentence is the reason this page exists.

Which one for your beard

By length. This is the factor that decides it. Beeswax is for hair long enough to need controlling. On stubble it is wasted and feels greasy.

Beard length guide: stubble oil only, short beard oil with balm optional, medium beard oil then balm, long or thick beard oil, balm and wax.

Beard stage Use Why
Stubble, 0 to 1 cm Oil only Skin care is the whole job. Nothing to hold yet
Short, 1 to 4 cm Oil, balm optional The itch phase. Oil fixes it. Balm only if hairs stick out sideways
Medium, 4 to 8 cm Oil, then balm Enough length to need shape. This is where most men add balm
Long or thick, 8 cm and up Oil, then balm, wax for styling Balm tames; wax sculpts. Both sit on top of oil

By skin. Oily or acne-prone skin: use less oil, not none, and choose one built on jojoba and squalane, which sit closest to what skin makes itself. Sensitive skin: avoid alcohol, silicones and parabens, which show up in cheaper products. Dry, flaky skin: oil is the priority, and the night application matters more than the morning one.

By climate. Hot and humid: oil in the morning, balm only if you need hold, because wax softens in heat. Cold and dry: both, and do not skip the night oil. Indoor heating pulls moisture out of a beard faster than any weather does.

What about beard butter and beard cream? Butter is for softening the hair itself: heavier conditioning than oil, softer and less hold than balm, best for coarse or very dry beards. Warrior's Beard Butter is back in stock from October 27, 2026. Cream is the lightest of the four, water-based, no hold, for men who want frizz control without any oil feel. We cover all three in Beard Cream vs Balm vs Butter. If your choice is only oil or balm, the length table above is the answer.

Warrior's Beard Butter 50 g tin by The Beard Struggle. Butter softens coarse hair. Warrior's Beard Cream 50 g jar by The Beard Struggle. Cream is the lightest option.

Do I put on beard oil before balm?

Yes, always. Oil goes on first, on a clean, towel-dried beard, so it can reach the skin. Balm goes on after, once the oil has had a minute to absorb. Put balm on first and the beeswax forms a barrier that keeps the oil on the surface, where it does nothing but shine.

Is it better to use beard balm or oil at night?

Oil. Night is when the skin repairs itself and when nobody needs your beard to hold a shape. Skin also loses more water through its barrier in the evening and at night than in the morning (Yosipovitch et al., Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 1998), which is why an overnight oil does more than a daytime one. A few drops of oil worked into the skin before bed does more for itch and flaking than any daytime product. Balm at night is wasted wax on a pillowcase. This is the reason we make a separate Night Liquid Elixir: the richer of our two oils, built on babassu and squalane to hold moisture on the skin for the hours you are not touching it. Use the lighter Day Tonic in the morning and this one at night.

Night Liquid Elixir beard oil by The Beard Struggle, the richer oil for overnight use.

What are the disadvantages of beard oil?

Three real ones. It has no hold, so it will not fix a beard that sticks out sideways. It can look greasy if you use too much, which is the most common mistake we see; start with three drops and add, never the reverse. And a cheap oil built on mineral oil or heavy coconut can clog pores on acne-prone skin. None of these are reasons to skip oil. They are reasons to use the right amount of the right one.

The mirror image of that mistake is the one I see most from beginners: balm on stubble. There is nothing to soften or shape yet, so the balm just sits on the face and makes it greasy, and if it is built on heavy oils and butters it can clog the pores underneath. Men with fine beard hair hit a version of the same problem at any length. Too much oil or balm weighs fine hair down and it loses its shape faster, so start with less than you think.

What is the 3-month beard rule?

Grow for three months before you judge the beard or shape it. Most men quit in weeks two to six, when the itch is at its worst and the growth looks uneven. By month three the hairs have caught up with each other and you can see what you actually have. For this comparison the rule matters because the first three months are an oil-only period: there is nothing to hold yet, and the itch that makes men quit is a skin problem that oil solves. We cover the rule in detail in What is the 3-month rule for beards?

Quick answers

Do I need beard oil or beard balm? Start with oil. It conditions skin and hair at every length. Add balm once the beard is long enough to need shaping, usually around 4 cm.

Can you use beard oil and beard balm together? Yes, and for a full beard that is the normal routine. Oil first on a clean, towel-dried beard, balm on top. 28% of our first-time customers buy both in the same order.

Does beard balm replace beard oil? No. Balm carries less oil per gram and cannot reach the skin through a thick beard. Men who start with balm alone are the group most likely to add oil later.

Which is better for an itchy beard? Oil. Itch is a skin problem and oil is the product that reaches the skin. Apply morning and night until it settles, usually a week or two.

Which is better for a short beard or stubble? Oil. Balm has nothing to hold at that length and will feel greasy.

Which is better for a long or coarse beard? Both. Oil for the skin and softness, balm for shape. If balm is not enough to control it, add a wax for styling rather than piling on more balm.

How often should I apply each? Oil once or twice a day, morning and night. Balm once, in the morning, after the oil. Wash the beard two or three times a week with a beard wash, not every day, or you strip the oil you just paid for.

How long does a bottle or tin last? We checked our own order data. Across 12 months of US orders, the median repeat customer buys a new 30 ml bottle of oil about every 47 days, roughly 6 to 7 weeks per bottle, and a new 50 g tin of balm about every 69 days, roughly 10 weeks per tin. Short beards and lighter users go longer. More than a quarter of the men who buy our oil (27%) come back for another within the same 12 months.

The verdict

Under 4 cm: oil, and only oil. Over 4 cm: oil every day, balm on top in the morning. If you are only buying one product, buy the oil. Three quarters of our customers do, and most of them never need anything else.

If you want to try before committing to a scent, the Scent Raider Kit has sample sizes of the oil in every scent. If you already know you want both, the Day Tonic + Night Elixir set and Warrior's Beard Balm are the two products in this article, and the Beard Essential Kit is oil, balm and wash together.

Scent Raider Sample Kit: eight beard oil sample bottles and eight beard balm sample jars in two open black boxes. The Beard Essential Kit by The Beard Struggle: beard oil, balm, wash and conditioner.

At week four, buy the oil and nothing else. What is struggling at week four is your skin, not your hair, and oil is the only one of these products that gets to it. Come back for balm when there is enough hair to shape.


About the author. Faiysal Kothiwala is the Founder & CEO of The Beard Struggle. He started the company in Vancouver in 2015 and still formulates its products. The brand hand-makes beard oil, balm, wash and conditioner in Vancouver and London and has served more than 500,000 customers across the US, Canada, the UK and Europe.

Share to

Comments

0 comments

Share your thoughts

Related Articles